Philippe Geoffrion
Level 7 Valued Member
Ahhh yes, okay I’ve seen this one. It’s pretty awesome.Yes and no. It's going from a handstand to a bent arm planche and back up again. I like the move because it takes the shoulder through a large ROM, and even if one doesn't practice the move freestanding, it's easily scalable from pike position, or with the feet elevated on something. Back before my shoulder injury in 2016, I was getting close to doing it in a straddle. Since then, my main battle has been re-educating my shoulders to move the way they need, which the left is stubbornly refusing to do. No direct shoulder pain, but my left scap refuses to upwardly rotate when it should despite all my best efforts, and my neck ends up picking up the slack, which leads to tension and headaches.... so I've been trying to find things that get it moving right without that happening, and doing "90"-degree pike pushups seems to be pretty close.
Simon makes it look like he weighs nothing when he does them....
Also, there are lots of calisthenics athletes and coaches who say you should train however you'd like. I think the mindful mover, Stephen Low, and Simon (above) all say that you probably get more benefit from doing dynamic work. Some folks out there also say that if you want to be good at statics, you have to train them at least some of the time. Given that muscles seem to gain strength throughout their entire ROM when trained at longer lengths, I'd say that dynamics probably have a lot of carryover.
Sorrry to hear about the shoulder. I’ve had a fair amount of trouble in this region as well. May I ask what caused it? I ruptured my pec/tore my labrum almost a decade ago and the aftereffects still linger…
I think a mix of both dynamic and static movements are beneficial. However, statics held for extended periods until struggle and shaking, I find counterproductive. I held an 8 second tuck planche today with little struggle and felt it better than holding a 12 second one that would exhaust me.
I also like “prying movements”. I’ve been practicing the piked/straddle planche position by sort of “nudging” myself in and out of it. It’s sort of a mix between dynamic and static.