all posts post new thread

Programming help long post

jmmiller41385

Level 1 Valued Member
Hello All,

This is my first post here. I apologize, it is a bit long but I get excited about talking about training. I have been training kettlebells strictly for a little over a year to augment BJJ training. I am a 38 year old male. I weigh about 265 pounds. I started with simple and sinister with a 35lb kb. I moved on to 10000 swings after a couple of months with a 53lb kb. When I completed that I started looking into some programs. I needed something with some linear progression to help with focus. The open-ended format of Simple and Sinister was difficult with my ADHD brain to be motivated with. This was a me problem obviously not a program problem. In looking for a program I found Geoff Neuperts work and started the Giant program. It took some time for me to get caught up with the volume but I loved it. This type of AMRAP program helped my jiu jitsu tremendously. I finished that program and I was really excited to have been able to finish it completely and found this type of program with the work lined out to be very helpful in keeping me motivated and consistent. After finishing the Giant I purchased Neuperts Kettlebell Max. I have about two weeks left on this program. I have been using 2x53s for clean and press and front squat, and 1x35 for snatches. I am averaging about 150-170 reps on the clean and press and front squat days that are 30 minute sessions and just hit 400 reps in the snatch on the 20 minute snatch days. I am looking forward to testing my rep max with the 53's.

I have been training 3 days a week rather than the prescribed four. Through trial and error I have landed on this split. I have been able to train 3 days a weeks consistently this entire time. With family and work commitments it has worked best. I plan to continue this moving forward.

This summer I had an opportunity to compete in a highland games event and was exposed to stone lifting and strongman type events. I now have several natural stones and a sandbag. I am looking to try and reconfigure my training a bit to help with these events. I have been currently been doing kettlebells in the mornings before work, doing any stonelifting after work in the afternoons but there has been no real rhyme or reason to what I have been doing.

In considering what to do after KB Max, for kettlebells I am thinking after I retest my rep max at the end of kettlebell max that I will restart the original Giant program all over with my new rep maxs for 20 minute sessions. The thought has crossed my mind to buy a new program but I am almost certain that that would not be necessary. I may sometimes get caught up in the new and shiny.

I got Neupert's bolt on barbell program and I am considering training 5/3/1 in the afternoons two days a weeks, doing deadlift and overhead press. I figure I will trade out squat for deadlift every other cycle. The third day of training I might throw in some stone lifting of some other kind of strongman/ throws event training. Jiu Jitsu is getting put on the back burner to a degree at this point. I will probably attend open mat sessions on a feel basis.

All this said, I have a couple questions. First, does this sound reasonable? After having written this all out it sounds like a pretty tall order. At the end of the day I am not willing to give up the conditioning that kettlebells have provided me. They have changed my body composition and I am as strong as I have ever been in the last 10 years since having kids. On the other hand I have been bitten by the iron game once again and would like to throw some barbell movement in there for old time sake just to see what I am capable of.

Second, does anyone recommend any throws/ stonelifting books or information? I know Matt Vincent had a book that I have not read. I have heard that the programming is very similar to 5/3/1 which I have some experience with.

Thanks for reading to the end. I realize this is a long post. As I mentioned before I get excited talking about training. I appreciate any and all feedback ahead of time. Thanks.
 
Second, does anyone recommend any throws/ stonelifting books or information? I know Matt Vincent had a book that I have not read. I have heard that the programming is very similar to 5/3/1 which I have some experience with.
Welcome!

Here is a course on stone lifting (as sandbag training) by John Odden:

I don't know the course, but John is certified by Strong First (Beast Tamer and Sinister too!) and Original Strength, and has 7 world records under his belt.

Here is his instagram channel: Login • Instagram
 
Last edited:
I haven’t ran it, just came across him since I bought a sandbag last week but Brian Alsruhe’s EDC seems it would tick a lot of boxes for you.


 
Hello All,

This is my first post here. I apologize, it is a bit long but I get excited about talking about training. I have been training kettlebells strictly for a little over a year to augment BJJ training. I am a 38 year old male. I weigh about 265 pounds. I started with simple and sinister with a 35lb kb. I moved on to 10000 swings after a couple of months with a 53lb kb. When I completed that I started looking into some programs. I needed something with some linear progression to help with focus. The open-ended format of Simple and Sinister was difficult with my ADHD brain to be motivated with. This was a me problem obviously not a program problem. In looking for a program I found Geoff Neuperts work and started the Giant program. It took some time for me to get caught up with the volume but I loved it. This type of AMRAP program helped my jiu jitsu tremendously. I finished that program and I was really excited to have been able to finish it completely and found this type of program with the work lined out to be very helpful in keeping me motivated and consistent. After finishing the Giant I purchased Neuperts Kettlebell Max. I have about two weeks left on this program. I have been using 2x53s for clean and press and front squat, and 1x35 for snatches. I am averaging about 150-170 reps on the clean and press and front squat days that are 30 minute sessions and just hit 400 reps in the snatch on the 20 minute snatch days. I am looking forward to testing my rep max with the 53's.

I have been training 3 days a week rather than the prescribed four. Through trial and error I have landed on this split. I have been able to train 3 days a weeks consistently this entire time. With family and work commitments it has worked best. I plan to continue this moving forward.

This summer I had an opportunity to compete in a highland games event and was exposed to stone lifting and strongman type events. I now have several natural stones and a sandbag. I am looking to try and reconfigure my training a bit to help with these events. I have been currently been doing kettlebells in the mornings before work, doing any stonelifting after work in the afternoons but there has been no real rhyme or reason to what I have been doing.

In considering what to do after KB Max, for kettlebells I am thinking after I retest my rep max at the end of kettlebell max that I will restart the original Giant program all over with my new rep maxs for 20 minute sessions. The thought has crossed my mind to buy a new program but I am almost certain that that would not be necessary. I may sometimes get caught up in the new and shiny.

I got Neupert's bolt on barbell program and I am considering training 5/3/1 in the afternoons two days a weeks, doing deadlift and overhead press. I figure I will trade out squat for deadlift every other cycle. The third day of training I might throw in some stone lifting of some other kind of strongman/ throws event training. Jiu Jitsu is getting put on the back burner to a degree at this point. I will probably attend open mat sessions on a feel basis.

All this said, I have a couple questions. First, does this sound reasonable? After having written this all out it sounds like a pretty tall order. At the end of the day I am not willing to give up the conditioning that kettlebells have provided me. They have changed my body composition and I am as strong as I have ever been in the last 10 years since having kids. On the other hand I have been bitten by the iron game once again and would like to throw some barbell movement in there for old time sake just to see what I am capable of.

Second, does anyone recommend any throws/ stonelifting books or information? I know Matt Vincent had a book that I have not read. I have heard that the programming is very similar to 5/3/1 which I have some experience with.

Thanks for reading to the end. I realize this is a long post. As I mentioned before I get excited talking about training. I appreciate any and all feedback ahead of time. Thanks.
No, I would not recommend that at all. I would absolutely not recommend doing more pressing work on a clean and press program.

1. What is your rep max with 2x53s for clean and press and front squat, and on the snatch? Those are really high numbers which makes me think you are very under belled. You might not be underbelled, but it looks to me like you are.

2. Are you training at home, or at a gym? Or a mix? (e.g. what do you have available and when)

Barbell bolt on is great, but 5/3/1 is definitely not really in lines with it. If you're doing a 3x / week clean and press program, I wouldn't have an issue adding squats after a session, I would not add more pressing, and I would have to play week by week with deadlift and bench. I think *I* would be fine deadlifting 5/3/1 style after doing Giant clean and presses. I think benching and Giant would be hard to program together, especially if you're doing Giant 3x / week.

As for adding stone lifting and carries - I would have no issue adding that after Giant and just be mindful of the overall fatigue, particularly in the grip, forearms, upper back, and low back. Understand that fatigue is cumulative, and the more you do the more you have to recover from, and that might 1) make you a little too achey the next few days and/or 2) make your next Giant session worse.
 
Second, does anyone recommend any throws/ stonelifting books or information



Don’t have anything for throws. But the stark center probably has some stuff.

There was a newsletter a while back talking about training for Highland Games. I believe the gist of it was do the big four barbell lifts, regular old cycling, and add them at 50% quickly for accessory work.

Also a couple recent articles called putting the wind beneath the stones.

Hopefully that helps with the stone lifting. The basics are get stronger (lift heavy things) and then lift stones.
 
No, I would not recommend that at all. I would absolutely not recommend doing more pressing work on a clean and press program.

1. What is your rep max with 2x53s for clean and press and front squat, and on the snatch? Those are really high numbers which makes me think you are very under belled. You might not be underbelled, but it looks to me like you are.

2. Are you training at home, or at a gym? Or a mix? (e.g. what do you have available and when)

Barbell bolt on is great, but 5/3/1 is definitely not really in lines with it. If you're doing a 3x / week clean and press program, I wouldn't have an issue adding squats after a session, I would not add more pressing, and I would have to play week by week with deadlift and bench. I think *I* would be fine deadlifting 5/3/1 style after doing Giant clean and presses. I think benching and Giant would be hard to program together, especially if you're doing Giant 3x / week.

As for adding stone lifting and carries - I would have no issue adding that after Giant and just be mindful of the overall fatigue, particularly in the grip, forearms, upper back, and low back. Understand that fatigue is cumulative, and the more you do the more you have to recover from, and that might 1) make you a little too achey the next few days and/or 2) make your next Giant session worse.
I never understood how so many people post such high numbers with the Giant programs. I ran the giant 3.0 and never got much past 20 sets in a session. Plus I know it would take a few days to feel strong again.
 
I never understood how so many people post such high numbers with the Giant programs. I ran the giant 3.0 and never got much past 20 sets in a session. Plus I know it would take a few days to feel strong again.
100%. I think it is easier to get those numbers the lighter the bells are, even if they're still a 5RM or 10RM. A 10RM with 2x32kgs is a totally different beast than a 10RM with 2x16kgs. I get that a 10RM is a 10RM, but at the same time ... its not. haha
 
100%. I think it is easier to get those numbers the lighter the bells are, even if they're still a 5RM or 10RM. A 10RM with 2x32kgs is a totally different beast than a 10RM with 2x16kgs. I get that a 10RM is a 10RM, but at the same time ... its not. haha
I just recently did giant 3.0 with double 36’s because that was my 5rm. There is no way I could do crazy volume week after week without getting hurt or burning out.
 



Don’t have anything for throws. But the stark center probably has some stuff.

There was a newsletter a while back talking about training for Highland Games. I believe the gist of it was do the big four barbell lifts, regular old cycling, and add them at 50% quickly for accessory work.

Also a couple recent articles called putting the wind beneath the stones.

Hopefully that helps with the stone lifting. The basics are get stronger (lift heavy things) and then lift stones.
LOL I appreciate the sum up get stronger and lift stones! Thanks for the resources.
 
I never understood how so many people post such high numbers with the Giant programs. I ran the giant 3.0 and never got much past 20 sets in a session. Plus I know it would take a few days to feel strong again.
Im wondering if I am counting my reps differently. Im counting total reps on both numbers. Thats clean and press and front squat numbers added together. So the last clean and press workout I did on KB max was 2x53, 9 rounds of sets of 4 and 5. So one set included 4 CP 4 FS, 5CP 5FS for a total of 18 reps per set. 18x9 = 162 reps. Am I looking at this correctly? Let me know. Thank you for the feedback!
 
No, I would not recommend that at all. I would absolutely not recommend doing more pressing work on a clean and press program.

1. What is your rep max with 2x53s for clean and press and front squat, and on the snatch? Those are really high numbers which makes me think you are very under belled. You might not be underbelled, but it looks to me like you are.

2. Are you training at home, or at a gym? Or a mix? (e.g. what do you have available and when)

Barbell bolt on is great, but 5/3/1 is definitely not really in lines with it. If you're doing a 3x / week clean and press program, I wouldn't have an issue adding squats after a session, I would not add more pressing, and I would have to play week by week with deadlift and bench. I think *I* would be fine deadlifting 5/3/1 style after doing Giant clean and presses. I think benching and Giant would be hard to program together, especially if you're doing Giant 3x / week.

As for adding stone lifting and carries - I would have no issue adding that after Giant and just be mindful of the overall fatigue, particularly in the grip, forearms, upper back, and low back. Understand that fatigue is cumulative, and the more you do the more you have to recover from, and that might 1) make you a little too achey the next few days and/or 2) make your next Giant session worse.
Thanks John this helps tremendously.

1. I don't know If I am underbelled. I responded to a prior post about numbers and lined out how I am coming up with my numbers. I'm not sure I am reporting them properly. I'm not too proud to say my technique may suck and I may need to slow down. My squats are definitely to depth but my flexibility at the moment sucks. I am in the process of trying to go see a PT in order to get some guidance on working on some things. I've been dealing with anterior pelvic tilt for a long time and it stresses my QL and Piriformis. I worked on hip mobility in some form since Kelly Starrett got his start all those years ago but have not been consistent. Need to find something I can trust and stick to it. A functional movement screen would be awesome, I am in Radford Virginia not sure one of those is close by. I think I saw there was one at the local university but I don't think that individual does them for the general public but I am not sure haven't checked in on it.

When I tested to start the KB max I was able to do 5 reps with 32s but that was at the high school i work at. The 32s at the high school are not the greatest. I bought rogues last year and the handles are great in my perspective. Im not going to try and swing 32s at high volume unless the handles are good. It had also been a significant period when I had done squats so I was nervous about starting with double 32s.

2. I train at home. I am high school teacher and have periodic access to an extensive weightroom but I train at home for the convenience. I own double bells in 16, 24, and have a single 32. I am working on getting a second 32 prior to the end of my current KB max cycle in order to get a good bead on where to start plus I can incorporate the heavier bells into some carry work as well.

I also have a sandbag that has a liner that I can vary the amount of weight. It goes up to 280. I currently have 200 pounds of sand.
I have 3 natural stones - 140, 120 and 285.
I have a barbell, squat stand, and about 315 pounds of bumpers from my crossfit days.

As for adding presses and the 5/3/1 - I currently don't own a flat bench, so I was considering over head press just from a convenience standpoint. I am still new to the kettlebell game and sometimes get the perspective that I need to tack on more and don't consider the cumulative work I put in during the workout. Would it be out of line to drop back and squat and deadlift rather than do the press? I don't think I can do all three lifts in a week. I think the cumulative work would put me in a hole fast. Truthfully adding squats and deadlifts may do just that. Maybe just deadlift work would be more of a place to start? This is a dumb question would adding deadlifts in once a week be helpful or not enough to make a difference? It seems like not enough.

Thank you for your input I greatly appreciate it!
 
I haven’t ran it, just came across him since I bought a sandbag last week but Brian Alsruhe’s EDC seems it would tick a lot of boxes for you.


I'll have to check this out, thanks!
 
LOL I appreciate the sum up get stronger and lift stones! Thanks for the resources.
Haha no problem.
Did forget to mention that a big sandbag is a great tool for stone training. They beat you up less and have great carryover. Get the big ironmind one, it’s a classic for a great reason!
 
Not sure how you will fit all that into life.

Here is how I fit in 531 with other stuff.

531... 2 days per week with a twist. The twist is that Day 1 is my normal 531 day and Day 2 is a practice day. I did a normal 531 workout Day 1 progression (I use 75,80,85 option for my x5 day with an AMRAP set of course) . Day 2 was 531 using the 65, 75, 85 x5 progression and I never AMRAP on it just did the minimum for practice. If a person found that hard perhaps x3 would work. I thought it was pretty easy.

Choose 2 or 3 lifts to focus on. Deadlift and OHP would be fine. I did Squat, Bench and a Row... I believe I did 3-4 sets of 8 for Row. The workout took just over 30 min with warm up. Day 2 was quicker as there was no AMRAP to recover from.


So in short,

Day 1 - 531 - Usual 531 loads with AMRAP. DL, OHP, 1 Assistance Exercise
Day 2 - 65,75,85 x5 (or 3) no AMRAP. DL, OHP, 1 Assistance Exercise

This allows one to get in and do other stuff on other days. Strongman, BJJ, Highland, whatever. You can probably program 2-3 days of other stuff in and around your 2 day 531.

I really only focused on doing the main lifts but with your KB history I would be tempted to do KB Clean and Press for 10 min one day as an assistance exercise and KB Front Squat on the other. OTOH you could just do some pull ups or something instead.

You might find yourself doing KB Work and Games events as one of your other workouts. Who knows.
 
Last edited:
Im wondering if I am counting my reps differently. Im counting total reps on both numbers. Thats clean and press and front squat numbers added together. So the last clean and press workout I did on KB max was 2x53, 9 rounds of sets of 4 and 5. So one set included 4 CP 4 FS, 5CP 5FS for a total of 18 reps per set. 18x9 = 162 reps. Am I looking at this correctly? Let me know. Thank you for the feedback!
@jmmiller41385 yeah that sounds right. I’m just lazy so I don’t typically try to push that many reps in a single session.

The Giant 3.0 is more strength based and calls to use your 5rm for the cl and press so naturally the amount of sets I could get in for the times stated in the program were not going to be super high. I remember Geoff Neupert making a post about how he felt was the best way to approach the program was to do:

Week 1: light
Week 2: medium so try to get a couple more sets than the previous week
Week 3: hard
Week 4: deload

Are you competing in jiu jitsu?
 
Thanks John this helps tremendously.

1. I don't know If I am underbelled. I responded to a prior post about numbers and lined out how I am coming up with my numbers. I'm not sure I am reporting them properly.
You seem to be counting fine. Did you do a test with 24s prior to running the program? Or after? And I want to be clear I’m not saying your high numbers are bad, just that I would encourage someone with such high numbers to test the next bell up if possible. Some folks just seem to get a ton of reps per session, and some get a lot less, so its not really a comparison.
When I tested to start the KB max I was able to do 5 reps with 32s but that was at the high school i work at. The 32s at the high school are not the greatest. I bought rogues last year and the handles are great in my perspective. Im not going to try and swing 32s at high volume unless the handles are good. It had also been a significant period when I had done squats so I was nervous about starting with double 32s.
Awesome job! Also if you’re going to run Giant next, you can always run giant single bell - IF you want to run 3.0 (5RM) with a heavier bell.
I also have a sandbag that has a liner that I can vary the amount of weight. It goes up to 280. I currently have 200 pounds of sand.
I have 3 natural stones - 140, 120 and 285.
I have a barbell, squat stand, and about 315 pounds of bumpers from my crossfit days.
Ok great, equipment definitely doesn’t seem to be a limiting factor. Some folks (me in the past) have bells in one place and barbells another and putting together a program with both can be tricky.
As for adding presses and the 5/3/1 - I currently don't own a flat bench, so I was considering over head press just from a convenience standpoint. I am still new to the kettlebell game and sometimes get the perspective that I need to tack on more and don't consider the cumulative work I put in during the workout. Would it be out of line to drop back and squat and deadlift rather than do the press? I don't think I can do all three lifts in a week. I think the cumulative work would put me in a hole fast. Truthfully adding squats and deadlifts may do just that. Maybe just deadlift work would be more of a place to start? This is a dumb question would adding deadlifts in once a week be helpful or not enough to make a difference? It seems like not enough.
I love 5/3/1, but my understanding from you post is you wanted to do Giant (3 days a week of clean and press) and then supplement it with deadlifts and barbell overhead presses following the 5/3/1 template. I don't think that would work with the presses - too much pressing. You could (I wouldn't necessarily suggest it) do Giant 2x a week and press 5/3/1 1x a week, but if you're going to be adding pressing you're going to take some pressing out somewhere else.

Adding squats and deadlifts to Giant is a lot more straightforward, as it becomes more about time available, fatigue management, deciding what is your priority, and learning how to do enough of the "extra" work without taking away from the main work.

To be honest, this is less about learning how to use kettlebells and more about "program smashing." We can totally cook up a program that does kettlebell clean and presses + barbell work (including barbell pressing), and we can use the autoregulated density style training of Giant with the 5/3/1 of barbells, but I think I would cap pressing days to 3x a week, so it would look more like ...

Giant Session 1Giant Session 25/3/1 Press Session
Giant Session 3Giant Session 15/3/1 Press Session
Giant Session 2Giant Session 35/3/1 Press Session

This means one block of Giant would take 6 weeks. You could obviously shuffle sessions around in a week, but the gist stays the same. Then for adding squats/deadlifts it has more to do with time available and desired frequency (both how many total sessions per week, how many times you want to squat/deadlift per week, and whether due to time/energy the squat/deadlift sessions need to be separate form your Giant/Pressing sessions or if they can done "on top of" the existing framework.

Thank you for your input I greatly appreciate it!
Always happy to help. :) Hopefully I'm understanding your goals/desires and am being clear.
 
Back
Top Bottom