all posts post new thread

Old Forum 5 questions for Pavel and the forum

Status
Closed Thread. (Continue Discussion of This Topic by Starting a New Thread.)

Pnigro

Level 3 Valued Member
Hello everyone!
I have 5 questions:
Question #1: I am doing S&S with my girlfriend about 3-4 times per week. Her problem is that the kettlebell handle always rubs against her inner tighs during the swings (particularly on the upswing). She says it’s because her legs are fat and there’s little space for the handle to go through. We have competition kettlebells with wide handles.
We have tried improving technique as much as possible but it still rubs her inner thighs. I worry that this might be acting as a “brake”, causing her explosiveness to be less than ideal.
Here’s an old video of her doing some swings: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yK_AM3CrZnM
The only solution I have come up with is for her to slightly rotate the handle inwards, but I don’t know if this is ok?
This lady does it: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HoFk55UdaPI" title="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HoFk55UdaPI">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HoFk55UdaPI</a>
I suppose there’s no problem with doing that. Right?
Question #2: When moving up in weight, I know women should jump from 16kg to 20kg for the getups. But for the swings, should they also jump to the 20kg? Or are they supposed to skip it and go straight into the 24kg?
Question #3: I have been working with the 24kg for a while now and don’t feel anywhere close to owning it. The obvious solution is increasing workout frequency (currently doing S&S only 3-4 times per week), but I was wondering if it’s ok to ocassionally have a “heavy day” and use the 32kg to encourage some extra adaptation and accelerate results.
Question #4: On S&S book there’s a part where it says that if I can’t do the getup slowly then I’m hiding some weakness. It makes sense to me, but does it also applies to the first stage of rolling to the elbow? I find that I need a little explosiveness in order to do that part. I push from my supporting leg and lift my chest to the opposite side. How am I supposed to do that slowly?
Question #5: I sit on my desk all day and find that it is terrible for my flexibility. I was thinking of applying the GTG concept to mobility and I was wondering what exercises would be better for that? I was thinking of doing lunges during the day, for example while going to the bathroom. Surely they can help with my tight hip flexors? Crawling might be another good exercise, but I can’t do them without my hip moving all over the place. What do you guys recommend?
Thank you,
Andrés
 
MY GOD, this forum has the worst edit functionality in the world.

Here are the questions again:

-

Hello everyone!

I have 5 questions:

Question #1: I am doing S&S with my girlfriend about 3-4 times per week. Her problem is that the kettlebell handle always rubs against her inner tighs during the swings (particularly on the upswing). She says it’s because her legs are fat and there’s little space for the handle to go through. We have competition kettlebells with wide handles.

We have tried improving technique as much as possible but it still rubs her inner thighs. I worry that this might be acting as a “brake”, causing her explosiveness to be less than ideal.

Here’s an old video of her doing some swings: <a title="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yK_AM3CrZnM" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yK_AM3CrZnM">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yK_AM3CrZnM</a>

The only solution I have come up with is for her to slightly rotate the handle inwards, but I don’t know if this is ok?

This lady does it: <a title="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HoFk55UdaPI" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HoFk55UdaPI">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HoFk55UdaPI</a>

I suppose there’s no problem with doing that. Right?

Question #2: When moving up in weight, I know women should jump from 16kg to 20kg for the getups. But for the swings, should they also jump to the 20kg? Or are they supposed to skip it and go straight into the 24kg?

Question #3: I have been working with the 24kg for a while now and don’t feel anywhere close to owning it. The obvious solution is increasing workout frequency (currently doing S&S only 3-4 times per week), but I was wondering if it’s ok to ocassionally have a “heavy day” and use the 32kg to encourage some extra adaptation and accelerate results.

Question #4: On S&S book there’s a part where it says that if I can’t do the getup slowly then I’m hiding some weakness. It makes sense to me, but does it also applies to the first stage of rolling to the elbow? I find that I need a little explosiveness in order to do that part. I push from my supporting leg and lift my chest to the opposite side. How am I supposed to do that slowly?

Question #5: I sit on my desk all day and find that it is terrible for my flexibility. I was thinking of applying the GTG concept to mobility and I was wondering what exercises would be better for that? I was thinking of doing lunges during the day, for example while going to the bathroom. Surely they can help with my tight hip flexors? Crawling might be another good exercise, but I can’t do them without my hip moving all over the place. What do you guys recommend?

Thank you,
Andrés
 
 


Welcome › Forums › StrongFirst Forum › 5 questions for Pavel and the forum




 






I have 5 questions:
Question #1: I am doing S&S with my girlfriend about 3-4 times per week. Her problem is that the kettlebell handle always rubs against her inner tighs during the swings (particularly on the upswing). She says it’s because her legs are fat and there’s little space for the handle to go through. We have competition kettlebells with wide handles.
We have tried improving technique as much as possible but it still rubs her inner thighs. I worry that this might be acting as a “brake”, causing her explosiveness to be less than ideal.
Here’s an old video of her doing some swings: <a title="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yK_AM3CrZnM" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yK_AM3CrZnM">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yK_AM3CrZnM</a>
The only solution I have come up with is for her to slightly rotate the handle inwards, but I don’t know if this is ok?
This lady does it: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HoFk55UdaPI&#8221; title=”https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HoFk55UdaPI”>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HoFk55UdaPI
I suppose there’s no problem with doing that. Right?

***** Rotating the handle, thumb towards the back, is fine.
Question #2: When moving up in weight, I know women should jump from 16kg to 20kg for the getups. But for the swings, should they also jump to the 20kg? Or are they supposed to skip it and go straight into the 24kg?

******  20 kg for both is fine.
Question #3: I have been working with the 24kg for a while now and don’t feel anywhere close to owning it. The obvious solution is increasing workout frequency (currently doing S&S only 3-4 times per week), but I was wondering if it’s ok to ocassionally have a “heavy day” and use the 32kg to encourage some extra adaptation and accelerate results.

***** in principle, yes, this is fine, but it would be best if you have someone review your form, if not in person then post a video here.
Question #4: On S&S book there’s a part where it says that if I can’t do the getup slowly then I’m hiding some weakness. It makes sense to me, but does it also applies to the first stage of rolling to the elbow? I find that I need a little explosiveness in order to do that part. I push from my supporting leg and lift my chest to the opposite side. How am I supposed to do that slowly?

**** it applies especially to the first stage.  How to do it?  A coaching and cueing question for your coach or after you post a video.
Question #5: I sit on my desk all day and find that it is terrible for my flexibility. I was thinking of applying the GTG concept to mobility and I was wondering what exercises would be better for that? I was thinking of doing lunges during the day, for example while going to the bathroom. Surely they can help with my tight hip flexors? Crawling might be another good exercise, but I can’t do them without my hip moving all over the place. What do you guys recommend?

*****  not a question I can answer based on an Internet forum post.  OS resets are always good.
Thank you,
Andrés

This reply was modified 2 hours, 51 minutes ago by <a title="View Pnigro's profile" href="http://www.strongfirst.com/users/pnigro/"></a> <a title="View Pnigro's profile" href="http://www.strongfirst.com/users/pnigro/">Pnigro</a>.
This reply was modified 2 hours, 49 minutes ago by <a title="View Pnigro's profile" href="http://www.strongfirst.com/users/pnigro/"></a> <a title="View Pnigro's profile" href="http://www.strongfirst.com/users/pnigro/">Pnigro</a>.



April 11, 2015 at 1:50 pm<a title="Reply To: 5 questions for Pavel and the forum" href="http://www.strongfirst.com/topic/5-questions-for-pavel-and-the-forum/#post-50692">#50692</a>


<a title="View Pnigro's profile" href="http://www.strongfirst.com/users/pnigro/"></a>
<a title="View Pnigro's profile" href="http://www.strongfirst.com/users/pnigro/">Pnigro</a>
Free Subscriber



MY GOD, this forum has the worst edit functionality in the world.

Here are the questions again:

-

Hello everyone!

I have 5 questions:

Question #1: I am doing S&S with my girlfriend about 3-4 times per week. Her problem is that the kettlebell handle always rubs against her inner tighs during the swings (particularly on the upswing). She says it’s because her legs are fat and there’s little space for the handle to go through. We have competition kettlebells with wide handles.

We have tried improving technique as much as possible but it still rubs her inner thighs. I worry that this might be acting as a “brake”, causing her explosiveness to be less than ideal.

Here’s an old video of her doing some swings: <a title="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yK_AM3CrZnM" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yK_AM3CrZnM">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yK_AM3CrZnM</a>

The only solution I have come up with is for her to slightly rotate the handle inwards, but I don’t know if this is ok?

This lady does it: <a title="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HoFk55UdaPI" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HoFk55UdaPI">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HoFk55UdaPI</a>

I suppose there’s no problem with doing that. Right?

Question #2: When moving up in weight, I know women should jump from 16kg to 20kg for the getups. But for the swings, should they also jump to the 20kg? Or are they supposed to skip it and go straight into the 24kg?

Question #3: I have been working with the 24kg for a while now and don’t feel anywhere close to owning it. The obvious solution is increasing workout frequency (currently doing S&S only 3-4 times per week), but I was wondering if it’s ok to ocassionally have a “heavy day” and use the 32kg to encourage some extra adaptation and accelerate results.

Question #4: On S&S book there’s a part where it says that if I can’t do the getup slowly then I’m hiding some weakness. It makes sense to me, but does it also applies to the first stage of rolling to the elbow? I find that I need a little explosiveness in order to do that part. I push from my supporting leg and lift my chest to the opposite side. How am I supposed to do that slowly?

Question #5: I sit on my desk all day and find that it is terrible for my flexibility. I was thinking of applying the GTG concept to mobility and I was wondering what exercises would be better for that? I was thinking of doing lunges during the day, for example while going to the bathroom. Surely they can help with my tight hip flexors? Crawling might be another good exercise, but I can’t do them without my hip moving all over the place. What do you guys recommend?

Thank you,
Andrés




Author
Posts


Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)



Reply To: 5 questions for Pavel and the forum



<a>HTML</a><a>Visual</a>


















































Path: <a>p</a>






You may use these <abbr title="HyperText Markup Language">HTML</abbr> tags and attributes:
Code:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Tags:


 Notify me of follow-up replies via email
Submit
 
Pnigro,

On the one-handers she's grabbing the bell on the pinky finger side instead of the thumb side.

And her legs are not fat.
 
Andres,

Q1: which swings rub her thighs, 2h or 1h?  She needs to pull her stance shorter for 1-h swings, and pronate on the back swing.  I advocate center or pinkie-side hooking of the handle for 1-h swings.   2-h swings have to cross the thighs lower than a 1-h swing or the handle will make contact.

Q2: "should", "supposed to"?  No.  Follow the body's adaptation.

Q3: not necessarily, and, yes.

Q4: drop a bell size.

Q5: yes.  Crawl until your hips stop bounding, and then, crawl some more.

The theme running through your post is: "impatience".  Relax.
 
1. Can you post a vid of her swings from the front? Her legs are not fat, she's just missing out a detail or two

2. We have a Filipino saying " He who walks when he steps on a thorn, it pierces deep" so always go slpw and conservative when loading

 

3. Its possible. Similar to #2, adding a single set would be a wise approach

 

4. Post a video. You might be sitting up more than rolling

 

5. Mobility GTG is awesome go for it
 
Thanks a lot everyone!!!

I'm about to make a new thread with videos to get some form critique.
 
Status
Closed Thread. (Continue Discussion of This Topic by Starting a New Thread.)
Back
Top Bottom