I rely on deadlifts and kettlebell presses to such an extent that I've added PTTP in the title of my blog here. I don't think there is any question that PTTP builds more strength and muscle than S&S or ROP. If we consider the simple fact of "working out" the body for maximum activation of the most muscles, PTTP has to win over the other two programs, and it does so in a mere fraction of the time! It comes as no surprise that PTTP was the only widely promoted program of Pavel's for a long time until ROP and S&S much later. So, to recap, in terms of strict muscular development and strength, PTTP is far ahead. However, this doesn't make it better in absolute terms than S&S (can't speak too much for ROP since I've only done it in spurts here and there) since S&S trains violent, enduring motion through the swings and complicated balance, endurance through the TGUs. The way I like to put it is PTTP is a pure strength building body building program, which can backup a sport, but S&S is itself a sport which can also backup another sport if you like. I think violent motions as in S&S count a lot too, but again, if we're talking just getting stronger and bigger muscles, PTTP wins.
However, because of S&S and judo, I do a hacked version of PTTP, which is heavy singles with the deadlift followed by heavy low rep presses with the kettlebell. I've got the bar set to 370lbs and I'll do 1, 2 (usually), or 3 reps with it at a time, often only once a day. I do sets of 3 with the 32kg kettlebell for presses. It all keeps me looking and feeling like a tank. I would never have thought of such a routine without the book.