Steve Maxwell Article : Dear Over-45 Trainee

Discussion in 'Masters (50+ years old)' started by Adam R Mundorf, Aug 12, 2018.

  1. Adam R Mundorf

    Adam R Mundorf More than 500 posts

  2. LoriLifts

    LoriLifts More than 2500 posts

    Thanks for sharing.
    It's so good I read it twice!
     
    Adam R Mundorf likes this.
  3. Stefan Olsson

    Stefan Olsson More than 500 posts

    Great stuff! Steve Maxwell, Andrew Read and Mark Sission needs more attention.

    Thank you for the article!
     
    sizzlefuzz and Adam R Mundorf like this.
  4. Adam R Mundorf

    Adam R Mundorf More than 500 posts

    You got that right. Steve truly walks the walk and doesn't shy away from the public's eye.
     
  5. BCman

    BCman Triple-Digit Post Count

    Thank you for that.
    I was just thinking that I need to back off a little, because of some recent aches and pains coming back.
    I'm playing the long (longevity) game now.
     
    Hasbro likes this.
  6. Adam R Mundorf

    Adam R Mundorf More than 500 posts

    You won't regret it. The greatest people look forward and work backwards.
     
  7. crazycanuck

    crazycanuck Quadruple-Digit Post Count

    As someone who started exercising in my mid 30's, and now is in this age 45+/getting just shy of 50 yrs age group, I am getting quite aware that I cannot pound at the exercise hard like I did in the first several years after I started. I was nodding my head at everything in this article...thanks so much for sharing it!
     
    Hasbro likes this.
  8. Abdul-Rasheed

    Abdul-Rasheed Quadruple-Digit Post Count

    Excellent stuff. A reality check! Thanks for sharing.
     
  9. North Coast Miller

    North Coast Miller More than 2500 posts

    He's right for the most part, but in some respects you can still improve on some facets, is just more difficult. The real difference seems to be holding onto the gains.

    Last Summer I nearly hit 200lbs without needing to open up a hole on belt, my heaviest lean weight ever. But the lbs came off quick when I stopped gorging. It was harder to eat the required calories than to do the lifting.

    Overall though, he's dead on. The problem is not many have optimized that 4-5 year training window. So for most there might still be some genuine gains in the tank and there's only one way to find out.
     
  10. Stuart Elliott

    Stuart Elliott More than 500 posts

    Adam R Mundorf likes this.
  11. LukeV

    LukeV More than 300 posts

    I agree and while I greatly enjoyed the article I thought it was unduly pessimistic about gains beyond 45, particularly since many lifters don't get serious about their programming until the easy gains of youth and enthusiasm have passed. If science didn't exist common sense would tell us that no-one can get bigger and stronger forever but I wouldn't use 3-5 years training or 45 years of age as the trigger points for "maintenance" in the way this article does. From memory Donnie Thompson broke the combined powerlifting world record at age 46!
     
    Antti likes this.
  12. Stefan Olsson

    Stefan Olsson More than 500 posts

  13. North Coast Miller

    North Coast Miller More than 2500 posts

    When it comes to aging and training I have to keep coming back to my man Clarence Bass. While he is definitely showing signs of aging in his muscle tone and presumably other aspects of his metabolism, the guy is a beast, and has been for years.

    He might be an aberration but if so I suspect it is his capacity for and ability to manage high intensity protocols, and not anything to do with genetics.


    Peak Shape - at 60

    ==As detailed in The Lean Advantage 3, Lovelace Foundation for Medical Education and Research in Albuquerque, New Mexico, measured my maximum heart rate for the first time in 1977, when I was a few months short of 40. It was 180, exactly in accordance with the standard formula (220 - 40 = 180). Interestingly, that was a few years after I began doing regular high-intensity aerobics.


    Since then, my maximum heart rate has been measured in a laboratory setting seven times -- at ages 44, 47, 50, 51, 55, 60 and 62 – and has consistently exceeded the predicted rate by an ever widening margin. In June of this year, the Cooper Clinic in Dallas recorded my maximum heart rate at 182. Confounding the formula, my maximum heart rate has remained 180 or higher for 22 years. Why have I been able to defy the rule? Am I an aberration?==

    and

    ==Evans and Rosenberg and their colleagues at the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Human Nutrition Center on Aging at Tufts University have found that "the muscles of elderly people are just as responsive to weight training as those of younger people." Startlingly, an 8-week program of strength training by 87- to 96-year-old women confined to a nursing home resulted in a tripling of strength and a muscle-size increase of ten percent.==
     
    Carl and Antti like this.
  14. Hasbro

    Hasbro Triple-Digit Post Count

    Very good article and I didn’t see a single thing in there I would disagree with. I’ve had to tone it down the last few years (just turned 60) and my body is much happier for it. My training goals now favor activities that focus on everyday functional type strength and mobility over Superman strength. A double body weight DL just isn’t important to me anymore. It comes with a lot of risk and I’ve never once found that kind of strength to come into play in my everyday life.

    Everyone will reach a point in their life when you have to swallow your pride and admit there are no more gains to be had without a lot of risk. Unfortunately for me I failed to admit it too late and now I have to live with the pain and injuries that resulted from it. S&S with a reasonable weight, calisthenics, and Original Strength concepts are working well for me right now. Nothing wrong with maintenance mode....especially when it’s your only choice.
     
  15. Bret S.

    Bret S. Quadruple-Digit Post Count Certified Instructor

    My experience is a little different than what Steve Maxwell describes, although I do agree with alot of what he says.
    Regarding muscle building at 60 I'm almost there yet find it no problem to build or maintain muscle mass, probably from having a past base of muscle built starting 42 years earlier. I know I can't match what I've done in the past but nonetheless I'm happy with the results of even a small amount of hypertrophy based training as my body seems to respond quickly.

    The area where I feel the effects of age is more in the speed/strength realm. I can still move fluidly and have the 'pop' and power throwing MA technique but I'd be fooling myself to think it hasn't diminished to some degree. I can still jump fairly well but the landings are a little tougher so I don't do too much of it.

    I know many people promote the idea of 'less is more' when it comes to training but again I believe it varies greatly from person to person. Using myself as an example I've always tended toward alot of training, that's what my body and mind are used to. These days I'm doing VWC 3-4 times/wk along with 2-3 strength sessions with MA training as well. VWC is very demanding so I'll take days off as needed. My markers for a day off are:
    - not enough sleep
    - not enough food
    - sore or stiff joints
    - flat muscles
    - a general feeling of malaise
    - dehydrated
    Since adopting VWC I'm in a flux state and figuring out training vs. rest days. Most people seeing my age and schedule would probably say I'm over training, but it's been my MO for so long it's what I'm accustomed to doing.
    As you train over many years you learn to read signals your body sends out and make adjustments accordingly. This is what I use to gauge training. Another development in the last couple of years is injury prevention strategy. It used to be if I felt a tweak while doing a set I'd note it but continue without issue, nowadays I've learned to stop immediately after one as it's a very small window of warning. When I don't listen often times I'll get something more serious on the very next rep.
    Right now I'm in the process of simplification and consolidation with training as I search for efficiency.
     
  16. Geoff Chafe

    Geoff Chafe Quadruple-Digit Post Count

    I did not like the blog post, and instantly disliked the author, but I am not the target audience. Weakness does not need more justification to be weak.
     
    Glen, Matts, jef and 5 others like this.
  17. Anna C

    Anna C More than 5000 posts Elite Certified Instructor

    Yeah I agree @Geoff Chafe, it didn't resonate with me either.
     
    Matts and Antti like this.
  18. ClaudeR

    ClaudeR Triple-Digit Post Count

    I had the same reaction... I know it is not what he said and he probably has a point (probably, but I’m only 40), but it sounds very much like giving an excuse for mediocrity. Yes you can’t progress eternally, no I don’t think we should ever accept that as fact and stop striving for improvement!
     
  19. North Coast Miller

    North Coast Miller More than 2500 posts

    For me, I feel the joints complain sometimes, and I definitely need to warm up a bit to get going. This is stuff I've read about for years, so no surprise I'm feeling it as well.

    The one aspect of aging I feel the most is my ability to cram calories - its just not there like it used to be, and that really is what limits any mass gains I might shoot for (although training at home and not having barbells and a cage is another limiting factor).

    I could make far better use of a professional dietician before I could use someone designing an exercise program for me.

    And then, I'm a relative pup at 50, but I still train with intensity, more so now than at any point over the last 10-15 years, and I feel a lot better for it.

    Not sure what Steve is trying to convey but I suspect it is for the older but inexperienced fitness enthusiast relative to marketing BS - which is full of misinformation at any age/stage of development. Of course there are limits - train intelligently and you'll find and push them, rush it and you'll get hurt. True at any age but definitely more true as you get older.

    Honestly I am far more prone to injure myself in day to day activities than I am training.

    Edit to add: Not liking this blog post, but overall I have learned more about kettlebells and fitness in general from his writings, video, and the one day cert I did with him, than anybody else out there. More often than not he is right on the money.
     
    Antti likes this.
  20. Bret S.

    Bret S. Quadruple-Digit Post Count Certified Instructor

    I think you nailed it with the marketing BS, maybe he went to the opposite extreme to illustrate a point, and this is where I agree with him. There's always some new supplement, workout, gadget etc.. coming along and it's all geared to making money, which is fine, as long as people are happy. It's like the person dieting, I'll try this diet, then I'll try that diet and...and.. All this stuff is geared toward the generic Joes depicted in beer commercials.

    Steve's attitude toward hypertrophy and training came off as defeatist in a sense (to me). As I said before I'm feeling none of what he describes. I don't think I'll build 20" arms again but I really have no desire to, all I want is to have a good strong, solid and functional muscularity, I'm pretty lean, 6' 2" and 190 lbs and have done very little hypertrophy work until the last couple of months, I've weighed 245 lbs in the past and still showed abs. I could go up to a lean 200 but that's the upper limit, 2 yrs ago I went up to 210 but felt clunky doing MA. There's nothing wrong with building muscle, I know your with me on this, it's nice to engineer the type, placement and quantity of muscle so in that sense I'm still a bodybuilder
     

Share This Page