North Coast Miller
Level 9 Valued Member
If an attacker attempts to stab or slash you he has to commit to the attack thereby leaving an opening to exploit, move and counterattack. I've spent many hours and years practicing knife defense, stab, slash, multiple slash, overhand, underhand, you name it.
I'm not saying I can't be stabbed but if I see it coming and have room to move I become a hard target. But that takes many years of specific training.
When an attacker has a knife in his hand that knife contains his spirit, he's vulnerable and he knows it. A well timed and powerful kihap can startle or shake an attacker, buying you precious milliseconds to take over. Sidesteps, low sweeps and dragon tails, kicking out knees, breaking joints. If I can get to his attacking side (as in beside him) he's dead
The scenario for training purposes was based on a sample of attacks boiled down to the most common attributes. One of those was the attack being launched at close range with no real display of the weapon beforehand. To be honest though, if they just charged you from ten feet it would still be trouble, esp if they changed angle at the last approach. Glancing blows and other hits that might give you the initiative open hands just put you in grabbing range.
Mot people will move away from the knife and that moves them toward the free hand. This leaves the free hand available to ward off counters and make an attachment. Once that happens you're in real trouble.
Most knife drills have the attacker lead with the knife but that isn't what happens. Knife attack isn't kick or punch range, its elbow/headbutt/uppercut/hook range. Another characteristic of most knife defense outside of FMA is the attacker going immediately to the trunk, but a trained attacker will hit the limbs first.
In fact a real freebie whether the attackee is trained or not is to feint to the lead hand and redirect to hit whatever they use for a counter on the way out - the unengaged hand or a kick. This work with a very high % of effectiveness. It doesn't take but one peripheral hit to once again close and make that connection, and then 5-7 hits/second.
It isn't hopeless, we were sometimes able to hit the attackers arm hard enough the knife came out even with a focus mitt held across the bicep. Some stuff will certainly work esp if the attacker isn't some energetic MA student coached on the highest percentage knife attack techniques. I believe he quoted a 10-20% at best survival rate. I'd like to think I'm closer to 30% at least
But one of the things you have to mentally prepare for is continuing with blood coming out of you. Unarmed against a knife its almost a certainty unless your man is a total joke or completely inebriated. The really good news is that cut and stab wounds are relatively easy to fix for the surgeon compared to gunshot.
Last edited: